Randy R. Bauman

	Randy R. Bauman is a partner at Delta Healthcare, a health care consulting firm in Franklin, TN. Neil H. Baum, MD, is professor of clinical urology at Tulane Medical School, New Orleans.

	In the first two articles in this three-part series on selling a practice, we discussed 

 that is equitable to both buyer and seller. Once a sale has been finalized, the next order of business is to transition the practice from the seller to the buyer. In this article, we switch to the buyer’s perspective and discuss the steps necessary for a smooth transition, with the goal of retaining as many existing patients as possible.

	The first step, and it’s a very important one, is the agreement in the contract for a period of overlap between the new urologist taking over the practice and the urologist who is leaving it. This overlap makes it possible for the exiting urologist to introduce the patients to the new doctor. A face-to-face introduction between doctors and patient, and assurance from the exiting doctor that patients will be in good hands with the new doctor, create a form of endorsement. During this overlap period, patients will have to decide if they are going to buy into the new doctor and his/her philosophy or search elsewhere for urologic care.

	This overlap also allows the new doctor to become familiar and comfortable with the existing staff and learn the process of the exiting doctor and staff. This includes managing patient flow from scheduling, examination, insurance, and patient follow-up. Of course, the new doctor can make changes in the staff, but this should probably be done at a later date and not during the overlap period. We suggest that the overlap period be a minimum of 6 months and not longer than a year.

	We suggest that the exiting doctor send a letter to patients with his intention of leaving the practice (retiring if that is the situation) and that the new doctor will be taking over his/her practice. This letter can enlighten patients on the training and skills that the new doctor will be bringing to the practice. It is important to mention that an overlap will take place so that the departing doctor can say goodbye and introduce the new urologist to patients.

	It is also recommended that the exiting doctor use the letter to explain to patients why they should remain in the practice. For example, the letter might mention that the medical records are in the practice, the staff knows the patients well, and patients will feel comfortable with the new doctor. We suggest that a hard copy be sent to the patient, but also send an email copy if the practice has been collecting email addresses.

How to improve health information online for our patients

	If you really want to be certain that patients stay in the practice, then we suggest the “extra mile” approach. This consists of having the exiting doctor personally call every patient. Although this phone call may appear awkward and even cumbersome to complete, it goes a long way in saying thank you and goodbye. In the call, the exiting doctor can thank patients for trusting their urologic care to the practice over the years and then recommend an appointment to meet the new doctor. This very nice gesture is way to leave a legacy not only with your patients but also with the referring doctors in the community, as they will certainly hear about your kindness and consideration.

	It is very helpful if the exiting doctor introduces the new doctor to physicians who provided referrals over the years. We suggest a face-to-face visit and requesting 5 minutes with the referring doctor.

	This meeting is not meant to go into detail about the transition process but rather should be a meet-and-greet occasion. Another suggestion is for the exiting doctor to take the new doctor to any staff meetings, grand rounds at the hospital, and any other social functions to introduce the new doctor to the medical community. We suggest that every referring physician you meet receive a follow-up note or email thanking them for their time and indicating that you will be looking forward to continuing the relationship that the exiting doctor had with the referring doctor.

	All stationary, brochures, and print material needs to be updated with the name of the new physician. Avoid the unprofessional look of a brochure with the name of the new doctor written under the name of the departing doctor. Spend the money to give yourself a professional look with professional-looking print material.

	Keep in mind that many older physicians have not embraced the Internet and social media. If you are buying a new practice, you want to have a robust Internet presence. This means an interactive website where patients can make appointments, pay their bills, and have their questions and concerns answered via email. You will also want to consider the use of social media and have Facebook, YouTube, and Twitter accounts.

	If the practice already has a website, then we suggest that you update the site, introducing the new physician, what his office schedule will be, and what insurance plans he accepts.

	You can announce your presence in the office with your name on the sign in the office directory and on the door of the practice. You don’t want to be hard to find. Make it easy by having adequate signage at strategic locations.

	The reception area is also an opportunity to announce the buyer’s presence in the practice. A poster with your picture and a very brief bio will alert the patients that there is a new urologist in the practice.

Planning for retirement: How much is enough?

	As a urologist, you will be dependent on referrals from other physicians and professionals like podiatrists, chiropractors, nurses, and pharmaceutical representatives. There’s no better way to introduce these colleagues than via an open house hosted by the practice. Be sure to also include the staffs of the potential referring physicians since they can be invaluable in making referrals. We suggest you collect email addresses of everyone who comes, then follow up with a personal thank you note.

	Everyone should have something to take with them that will reinforce your services and your unique areas of urologic interest and expertise. Pamphlets, business cards, swag items (like a water bottle or stress ball with the practice logo) will help colleagues and their staff remember you long after the event ends.

	Find a mentor besides the doctor selling the practice. Certainly the urologist who is selling the practice will be able to show you how the practice is run and how to care for the patients. The seller will also show you the business aspects of your new practice. However, you will need to “learn the ropes” of the hospital community. We suggest seeking an older physician, who is not a urologist but has a stellar reputation and the time to devote to introducing you to other colleagues in the medical community. This can be an invaluable resource, especially at the beginning of the transition process.

	It has been our experience that practices that undergo a smooth transition from seller to buyer can achieve patient retention rates as high as 90% to 95%. But for those without a plan, retention rates may be as low as 50% or worse. There are so many ways to build a patient base for a new physician, but like everything else, you must have a plan. Get your plan in place before the new doctor arrives so he or she can hit the ground running. Starting a successful medical practice is doable and offers many advantages, such as autonomy and ability to make business decisions affecting the practice. Despite all the changes happening in health care, we still think this is the best way to go.

	The Medical Group Management Association provides an excellent check list for any urologist buying a practice, available at 

The ‘post-truth’ world: How it’s drifting into medicine

Redefining the culture of NP-physician collaboration

Articles

Neil Baum, MD, and Randy Bauman discuss their tips to making the transition from practice seller to buyer as seamless as possible to keep patient retention rates high.

From seller to buyer: Tips for a smooth transition

	Probably the two greatest times of stress for urologists are the day they start their practice and the day they decide to leave the practice and put it up for sale.

BCG instillation: Why you can’t get reimbursed for catheters

	One of us (NHB) started a practice in 1976. At that time, most urologists continued to practice until shortly before they died-almost with the scalpel in their hand or cystoscope in the bladder. Today, many urologists are seriously contemplating leaving active practice at age 55, 60, or, more traditionally, 65.

	Urologists in a group practice, even those with just one or two partners, presumably have in place a well-thought-out and properly drafted contract with buy-out and “phase-down” provisions. For group practices, it is imperative that the members critically review, discuss, and decide whether their contractual arrangements make sense for these times. Urologists who have done so have an exit strategy that is fairly self-executing, effective, and provides the seller with a seamless transition to retirement.

	Urologists contemplating leaving practice consider selling for two main reasons:

		to realize some value for the work performed in establishing, growing, and maintaining the practice

		to ensure their patients are cared for when they retire or leave the community.

	Both of these are laudable goals. Of course, you want your patients to be taken care of and you want to provide those patients and your established referral base with an avenue of continuity. Wanting to realize value for what you have created and invested in over several decades is also certainly appropriate.

	People wishing to sell their home who put a "For Sale" sign on their front lawn without any advance preparation don't maximize the value of their home, and the same is true of medical practices. Regardless of who takes over your practice, you need to prepare in advance to segue your practice to your partner(s) or to another urologist.

	The first step is the real estate equivalent of curb appeal or how your practice looks from the outside looking in. If you've been in practice long enough to consider retirement, you want to make sure your office doesn't still have that circa-1963 look. While a total remodel may not be possible or economically feasible, updating the worn carpet, painting the reception area, adding some new furniture, and doing some general housecleaning is usually a good place to start. Potential buyers can be very image conscious, and something that looks old is generally viewed as having less value.

	Knowing your practice's finances and ensuring they are in order is the most important aspect of selling your practice. Any serious buyer will ask to examine your books, look at how you run your business, and assess the potential growth and vitality of the practice. They will want to know where the revenue comes from and where it goes.

	You should strive to show a stable or growing revenue base, an attractive payer mix, reasonable overhead, and a personal income that is at least stable and hopefully increasing. If your earning capacity is low or has been declining, you need to be able to explain why.

	When looking at personal income, don't forget to normalize your income by adjusting for varying levels of non-standard physician benefits and discretionary expenses that often are included in practice overhead. For example, rich retirement plan contributions and expensive cars that are paid for by the practice make your income look artificially low. However, if you explain your rationale for these expenses, your profit and loss statements will look more attractive.

Next: Selling to a newly recruited urologist or to other physician groups

	In selling a practice, a solo physician has three basic options: finding a successor physician, selling to another physician group, or selling to a hospital. A fourth option, of course, is simply closing down the practice.

CMS data: Health care spending continues to rise

	We strongly recommend beginning the process well in advance of the intended exit date. This is critical for several reasons:

	First, it is not unusual for the process of recruiting a successor urologist to take several (3 to 5) years. Recruiting is difficult and candidates are in short supply in many areas. Many potential buyers are spoken for well in advance of completion of their training.

	Second, the value of a practice often starts to decline when it becomes known the physician is going to retire. This is because the universe of potential buyers knows that patients will seek care somewhere else and the closer you are to retiring, the less likely they will remain in your practice and accept care from your new associate.

	Third, while not a pleasant thought, any delay in the exit process puts you at a risk that death or disability will intervene, ruining almost any chance for your family to realize a financial return on your many years of hard work in building a successful practice.

	By starting as much as 5 years in advance, you can maximize the likelihood of retaining most, if not all, of the practice’s value. It allows for thoroughly exploring all available options and finding a committed buyer.

	When considering the sale of a practice, look at it from the standpoint of potential buyers. Depending on your market, those buyers could include:

		a larger single- or multi-specialty group operating in the area

		the local hospital where you primarily practice

		other local hospitals where you may or may not maintain some level of privileges.

	Selling a practice is often complicated and most urologists lack skill in this area. So much of the success in selling depends on the specifics of the practice, the physician, and the market-ie, the hospital and physician environment-in which they operate.

Recruiting another urologist to acquire and continue the practice may feel like the best option, but in the current environment, this decision can be one of the most difficult, especially with younger physicians. The current generation of younger physicians tends to be risk-averse and lacks interest in the business side of medicine.

As you work down the list of potential buyers, you should also quietly, subtly, and tactfully look at existing practices (even if you consider them competitors) to see if any of them would like to merge with and/or acquire your practice, acquire your charts and records, and gain access to your referring physicians.

	An existing urology group will often be the best potential buyer for several reasons. First, it may have the financial capacity to pay a fair price. Second, it can most easily facilitate the transition by allowing you, the seller, to phase out gradually. Finally, it may have the strongest reason to do the deal-protecting its “turf” so a younger physician with more and newer skills doesn't take over your practice and create a stronger and more formidable competitor.

	In our experience, urologists typically refrain from broaching the subject of retirement with their colleagues. They often feel embarrassed to admit they plan to take this step. In holding back, however, they lose out on perhaps their best possible transition opportunity. If you are contemplating retirement, you should feel comfortable quietly raising the thought and flat-out asking a colleague if his or her group would be interested in discussing how you might work together toward this goal.

Lifestyle creep: What is it, and how do you avoid it?

	The key here, again, is to not wait too long. Regardless of professional and personal relationships, any potential buyer will reject paying for something they think they can get for free. What you want to be "selling" is your willingness to transition your patient and referral relationships over a period of time.

In the current health care environment, where over 50% of physicians have become employed by hospitals, this may be a viable option.

	Your practice probably contributes millions of dollars of income annually to the hospital, and the hospital would like to maintain this revenue stream. Talking to the hospital CEO or medical director is something to consider.

	The local hospital needs urology services. Even in areas where there are multiple physicians practicing urology, these practices are usually full and your departure will likely leave the market with reduced capacity.

	Hospitals also know that patients will seek care elsewhere if the market can't absorb the additional demand resulting from your departure. Patients will either go to a competing hospital or leave the community and travel elsewhere for care. Either of these two potential outcomes result in a loss of market share for the hospital, and the obvious solution is to recruit a replacement.

	The goal is to negotiate a transitional model where a replacement urologist is recruited and, with the financial support of the hospital, the practice is transitioned to that urologist over a specified period of time.

	The hospital could acquire your practice and employ you during this transition or simply provide recruiting support and an income guarantee to your practice to help pay the cost of the new physician's salary. Which direction is taken-selling or remaining independent-will often be driven by the needs and desires of the new recruit. The vast majority of physicians coming out of training today want to be employed, so expect this option to work in most cases if you plan to sell to a hospital.

	Selling to a hospital at the end of your career isn't all bad. If you are starting a few years before retirement, you might find employment a welcome respite from the daunting responsibility of managing your own practice. And this kind of transition can result in a stress-reduced lifestyle as you introduce and transition your patients to the new urologist and work less, including less call, while maintaining (or even increasing) your income.

	Nearly every urologist will be confronted with the decision on exiting his or her practice. Most of us have very little experience with this process. However, if you follow the suggestions we have provided you, plan in advance, and receive good advice, your exit strategy can be successful and even enjoyable. In the next article in this three-part series, we will discuss practice valuation and how to determine the appropriate amount you might receive from the sale of your practice.

CMS releases pay, Quality Payment Program rules

Final rule: Good news, bad news for urologists

Estate planning: Don’t make these mistakes

 to get monthly news from the leading news source for urologists.

Randy R. Bauman

Articles

From seller to buyer: Tips for a smooth transition

Selling your practice: How to start the process